SLeague Reviewing Form

V1.1 Last modified 05-11-98

Please read carefully. Additional info is included below.
Text in Italics is not an integral part of the form, it
is for explanation purposes only.
Text between brackets indicates spaces to fill in.

---
GENERAL CLASSIFICATION

* [Fantasy/Fictional/Historical]
An example of a Fantasy scen would be Midgard,
a Fictional scen would be WW79 and a historical
one would be WW1.

* [Title and name of the author]

* [Global (and short) description of the setting]

* [Specifics:]
   [1]        [-Map Size]
   [2]        [-Timespan]
   [3]        [-New units/improvements etc]
   [4]        [-New concepts/clever tricks]

THE REVIEW

* [Your name]

* [Overall Score: 1-10]
This is the overall feeling the reviewer has after
judging the scen (see below) and takes comments into
account as well. The scoring ranges from 1 to 10. 1 is 
considered awful, while 10 is excellent. 

* [Playability: 1-10]
The points below are to be scored separately. There is
no need to score them in a numerical fashion like the general
categories. This is the place where you can blabber verbally
about the scen. Don’t forget to score the general category, 
though! 
   [1]    -is the scen fun to play, does it pose a
         challenge, or is it too simple/complicated?
   [2]    -are there direct faults in the scen?
   [3]    -is there an appropriate atmosphere? (obtaining
         plastics in the dark ages would destroy the atmo)
   [4]    -is the scenario well balanced?
   [5]    -free comment

* [Level of General Care: 1-10]
   [1]    -is the map adequate
   [2]    -is the documentation OK
   [3]    -is the tech tree in proper order
   [4]    -are details taken care of (civilopedia, city names)

* [Artwork/Originality: 1-10]
   [1]    -how's the artwork?
   [2]    -are there good, or original ideas in the scen?

---
Reviewers should score the scen on all foresaid categories,
and should feel free to include free comments where necessary.
Scoring is done as follows: the relevant category (like:
Artwork/Originality) should be rated from 1 to 10. Motivation 
is nice, but optional. Keep in mind that you might be reviewing 
a scen from someone who has put a lot of effort into it, so if 
you’re gonna be harsh, then at least motivate your reasoning well.

This form should be sent to Blackclove by email at 
Blackclove@Geocities.com The results will be placed on
a website hosted by Apolyton.
Please try to complete the review of a scenario within a week's
time, as we’ve got lots of scens to review.

A last thing about the reviewing process. We intend to move the
Sleague more towards active discussion on the scens that were 
reviewed, so that the authors as well as everyone else can learn
from it. As a start, some threads will be placed on the Apolyton
Community Forum. Your contribution is greatly appreciated!

That's it! Goodbye and keep civvin' -El Khan

@end of file